In short: Shopify Plus is usually the better fit for mid-market B2B brands that want to run DTC and wholesale in one operating environment with less platform maintenance. Adobe Commerce (Magento) remains the stronger option when the business needs deep code-level customization, negotiable quotes and approval workflows, or commerce rules Shopify cannot support reliably through native features, apps or integrations.
Choosing between Shopify Plus and Magento is not really a platform-feature comparison. For a mid-market B2B brand, it is an operating-model decision.
You are deciding how much custom infrastructure your team wants to maintain, how easily wholesale and DTC can work together, and whether your catalog, pricing, ERP and buyer workflows fit the platform you choose.
Adobe renamed the paid edition of Magento to Adobe Commerce in 2021. The name changed, but the decision many manufacturers, distributors and wholesalers face is the same: should you keep a highly customizable platform that demands technical ownership, or move to Shopify Plus and simplify how your business runs ecommerce?
The short answer: Shopify Plus is usually the better fit for mid-market B2B brands that want to run DTC and wholesale in one operating environment with less platform maintenance. Adobe Commerce remains a strong option when your business requires unusually deep code-level customization, highly specific quote workflows, or commerce rules that Shopify cannot support reliably through native features, integrations or custom development.
The right answer depends on your actual requirements, not the features that sound impressive in a sales demo. This guide is written for B2B and hybrid brands. For a general platform comparison, see Shopify vs Magento vs BigCommerce, and for running costs and admin burden, see Magento vs Shopify for mid-market merchants.
Magento, Adobe Commerce and Shopify Plus: what is the difference?
Magento Open Source is the free, open-source ecommerce platform. Adobe Commerce is the commercial product formerly called Magento Commerce. It is built on the same open-source core and adds commercial modules, including Adobe's B2B features, along with cloud hosting options and Adobe support. Adobe now offers it three ways: self-hosted, on Adobe's cloud infrastructure, and as a SaaS product, Adobe Commerce as a Cloud Service.
Shopify Plus is Shopify's enterprise plan. It runs on the same core commerce platform as every Shopify store, with additional capabilities for larger and more complex brands, including higher API capacity, more advanced customization, multi-market support, automation and the full set of Shopify B2B features.
The biggest practical difference is ownership. With Adobe Commerce, your business has greater control over the underlying code and technical architecture. That also means more responsibility for upgrades, patches, hosting decisions, extensions, infrastructure and development capacity. With Shopify Plus, Shopify manages hosting, security patching, platform upgrades and core infrastructure, so your team focuses on operating and improving the store rather than maintaining the platform.
The comparison at a glance
| Decision area | Shopify Plus | Adobe Commerce |
|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Mid-market B2B and hybrid DTC brands seeking simpler operations | Enterprises needing deep code-level flexibility |
| Hosting and infrastructure | Included and managed by Shopify | Self-hosted, Adobe cloud infrastructure, or SaaS with Adobe Commerce as a Cloud Service |
| B2B and DTC | Run together with shared products, inventory and customer data | Can support combined B2B and DTC with more custom configuration |
| B2B catalogs and pricing | Companies, locations, catalogs, quantity rules, volume pricing and payment terms | Shared catalogs, contract pricing, company hierarchies, negotiable quotes and requisition lists |
| Quotes | Usually draft orders or an app | Negotiable quotes and quote templates built in |
| Customization | APIs, Shopify Functions, apps and headless options | Full codebase control, custom modules, APIs and composable architecture |
| Upgrades and security | Managed by Shopify | Requires ongoing technical planning and maintenance (lighter on the SaaS version) |
| ERP and operational integrations | Connectors, apps, middleware and APIs | APIs and custom integration work |
| Ongoing technical burden | Lower | Higher |
| Best reason to choose it | Operational simplicity | Maximum flexibility for unique requirements |
Where Shopify Plus is strongest for mid-market B2B
The strongest argument for Shopify Plus is not that it can do everything Adobe Commerce can do. It cannot, and that is not the point. Many mid-market B2B businesses do not need unlimited technical flexibility. They need reliable B2B workflows, accurate data, an easier operating model and a platform their commercial team can manage without opening a development ticket for every change.
Unified B2B and DTC operations
Many manufacturers and distributors sell through multiple channels: directly to consumers, to wholesale accounts, to retail partners or through sales representatives. Shopify lets these channels run from a shared commerce foundation. Products, inventory and customer data stay connected while each buyer group sees the pricing, products, terms and checkout options appropriate to them. That matters when you do not want separate platforms creating separate inventories, customer records and reporting problems.
A hybrid brand can use Shopify to provide:
- Public DTC product and collection pages
- Company-specific B2B catalogs
- Customer-specific pricing
- Quantity rules and volume pricing
- Buyer permissions
- Purchase-order numbers
- Negotiated payment terms
- Reordering and account self-service
- Shared inventory and product records across channels
For a mid-market brand, this is often a meaningful simplification.
B2B workflows without rebuilding the basics
B2B buyers do not shop like DTC customers. They need negotiated pricing, account-level access, purchase orders, terms, quick ordering and visibility into orders placed by their company.
Shopify B2B supports company accounts, company locations, catalogs, quantity rules, volume pricing, payment terms and account permissions. A buyer can log in, see the products and prices assigned to their company, place an order on agreed terms and review order history without relying on email or manual sales support for every repeat purchase.
Shopify Plus matters most when you need unlimited catalogs or catalogs assigned directly to individual companies. That is a practical advantage for brands with multiple buyer segments, regions, dealers, distributors or negotiated account agreements.
Lower infrastructure burden
Adobe Commerce gives you flexibility. It also creates recurring technical work. Your team needs a plan for upgrades, patches, extension compatibility, hosting, performance, security and development availability. For some organizations, that is a reasonable tradeoff. For others, it is an expensive distraction from selling products and serving customers.
Shopify includes hosting, SSL, bandwidth, security patching and platform upgrades. That does not remove the need for quality development work. You still need thoughtful theme customization, data modeling, integrations, testing and ongoing optimization. But it changes the amount of foundational platform work your team must carry.
A better fit for operational teams
A mid-market B2B business often has a small ecommerce team: a merchandising lead, an operations manager, a marketing lead and internal IT support. It may not include a dedicated Adobe Commerce engineering team.
Shopify is usually easier for non-developers to operate day to day. Your team can manage products, collections, content, orders, B2B companies, merchandising, promotions and many B2B workflows in one admin. The platform does not eliminate process complexity, but it reduces the number of routine changes that require custom code.
Where Adobe Commerce is still the stronger choice
Shopify Plus is not automatically the right answer for every B2B company. Adobe Commerce can remain the better choice when your business has requirements that depend on deep platform-level control.
Highly customized quote and procurement workflows
Adobe Commerce's B2B features include company account hierarchies, shared catalogs, negotiable quotes, quote templates, requisition lists, company credit lines, buyer roles and purchase order approvals.
Shopify covers many common B2B requirements, but it has no native equivalent of negotiable quotes. Quoting on Shopify usually runs through draft orders or an app. If your commercial process depends on a deeply customized quote engine, a unique procurement workflow or complicated account-spending rules that are central to your business, Adobe Commerce may be the more natural fit.
Do not assume a custom requirement is automatically a reason to stay on Magento. First, identify whether it is truly required, whether it can be simplified, and whether Shopify can support it through native functionality, an app or custom development.
Complete code-level control
Adobe Commerce is designed for businesses that need to control nearly every layer of the commerce stack. That flexibility is valuable when you need to build unusual business logic into the platform itself. For example:
- Complex configuration engines
- Highly specialized product pricing
- Advanced account hierarchies
- Unique quote and approval workflows
- Deeply customized procurement processes
- Composable architectures with specialized front ends
- Custom integrations that do not fit a standard connector model
The tradeoff is that flexibility must be paid for through development, quality assurance, maintenance and governance.
Established Adobe investment
Some businesses have already built a mature Adobe Commerce environment, with strong internal technical ownership, well-maintained integrations, documented workflows and an engineering team that can manage upgrades and ongoing platform work.
In that situation, a migration to Shopify needs a strong business case. The question is not whether Shopify is newer or easier to market. It is whether the migration reduces cost, operational friction or time to market enough to justify the effort and risk.
B2B pricing and catalogs: how the platforms compare
Pricing complexity is usually where platform decisions become real. A B2B business may have dealer pricing, distributor tiers, account-specific contracts, volume breaks, regional availability, tax exemptions, payment terms and sales-rep exceptions. Both platforms can support complex pricing. The difference is how much configuration, customization and maintenance your business must take on.
Shopify B2B pricing
Shopify B2B is available on the Basic, Grow and Advanced plans as well as Plus. On every one of those plans, it supports:
- Companies and company locations
- B2B catalogs with fixed prices or percentage adjustments
- Quantity rules and volume pricing
- Payment terms and purchase-order numbers
- Buyer permissions by location
- Customer-account ordering, quick order lists and reorders
Shopify Plus adds:
- Unlimited catalogs, where the other plans allow up to three
- Catalogs assigned directly to a company
- Deposits, partial payments and payment requests per fulfillment
Our guide to Shopify B2B setup decisions has the full plan-by-plan table.
This works well when your pricing model can be represented through customer or company-specific catalogs and rules. The key question is whether your current pricing logic needs to be copied exactly. Many Magento stores have accumulated years of custom exceptions that no one would build again from scratch, and a Shopify migration can be a chance to simplify them.
Adobe Commerce B2B pricing
Adobe Commerce supports company accounts, shared catalogs, contract pricing, negotiable quotes, requisition lists, company credit and more complex account structures. It can be the better fit if your pricing or procurement model is so specialized that it needs custom application logic.
But be careful. "Custom" is not always the same as "strategically necessary." Before deciding that your current pricing model requires Adobe Commerce, document every rule and ask:
- Does this rule still support the business?
- Can it be handled through a catalog, price list or the ERP?
- Does the sales team need it, or did it exist to work around an old limitation?
- What would happen if we simplified it?
ERP, PIM, OMS and 3PL integrations
Neither platform removes the need for integration planning. Your ERP, PIM, OMS or 3PL may be the source of truth for inventory, product information, orders, fulfillment or customer data, and the platform needs to work around that reality.
Shopify Plus integrations
Shopify supports integrations through apps, connectors, middleware, custom apps and APIs. For many mid-market companies, established connectors reduce the need for custom integration work. But a connector is not an integration strategy. You still need to define:
- Which system owns product data
- Which system owns inventory
- Where customer records originate
- Where pricing is calculated
- How orders are transmitted
- How fulfillment updates return to Shopify
- How failures are monitored and resolved
- Who owns each workflow after launch
Shopify can integrate effectively with ERP systems. The important work is not choosing an app. It is mapping the order lifecycle and data ownership before development starts, which we cover in 10 Shopify moves for migrations, B2B and ERP.
Adobe Commerce integrations
Adobe Commerce provides REST and GraphQL APIs and can support deeply customized integrations. That level of flexibility is useful for unusual enterprise environments. It also means your business may need more specialized technical resources to build and maintain those integrations.
For mid-market companies, the real decision is whether the deeper flexibility creates meaningful business value or simply creates more maintenance work.
Total cost of ownership
Platform license fees are only one part of the cost. The real comparison includes implementation, hosting, extensions, infrastructure, security, upgrades, performance work, integration maintenance and the developers required to keep the platform stable.
Shopify's comparison page puts its total cost of ownership 29% better than Adobe Commerce's on average, with Adobe's platform fees and ecommerce stack costs 42% higher. Those figures come from a study Shopify commissioned covering North American merchants from December 2023 to January 2024, so treat them as directional rather than a guaranteed result for your business. Our Magento vs Shopify cost breakdown covers the line items in more detail.
Your own total cost of ownership model should include:
- Platform fees
- Hosting and infrastructure
- Payment costs
- Apps and extensions
- Development retainers
- Upgrade and patching work
- Security and compliance costs
- ERP, PIM, OMS and 3PL integration maintenance
- Internal staff time
- Cost of delayed launches or feature releases
The best platform is not the one with the lowest first-year budget. It is the one that supports your revenue model without creating unnecessary operational drag.
The decision framework
Choose Shopify Plus when:
- You run or plan to run B2B and DTC together.
- You want shared products, inventory and customer data across channels.
- Your B2B model fits catalogs, customer-specific pricing, payment terms, quantity rules and account-level permissions.
- You want to reduce platform maintenance and upgrade work.
- Your ecommerce team needs to make routine changes without development dependency.
- You are willing to simplify legacy Magento customizations that no longer create real value.
- You need senior help connecting Shopify with an ERP, PIM, OMS or 3PL.
Choose Adobe Commerce when:
- Your business depends on highly specialized quote, approval, pricing or procurement workflows.
- You need complete code-level control over the commerce platform.
- Your team has the technical resources to maintain the platform properly.
- You already have a stable Adobe Commerce implementation with well-documented integrations and a clear operating model.
- Shopify would require too many compromises or fragile custom workarounds to meet your core requirements.
What a migration decision should look like
Do not choose Shopify Plus because Magento feels old. Do not stay on Adobe Commerce because your existing store is complicated.
Start with an honest requirements audit. Document your catalog, pricing, integrations, buyer roles, sales workflows, fulfillment process and reporting needs. Then classify each requirement:
- Native in Shopify
- Supported through Shopify configuration
- Supported through a proven app or connector
- Supported through custom development
- Not a good fit for Shopify
- A legacy process that should be retired
That process gives you a real answer. It also prevents a common migration mistake: rebuilding every old Magento customization before asking whether the business still needs it. If the answer is Shopify Plus, our Magento to Shopify Plus migration guide covers the process from audit to cutover.
How Kirkby, White Consulting helps B2B brands make the decision
Kirkby, White Consulting works with 7–9 figure DTC and B2B brands that have outgrown their current ecommerce operating model.
Best for: Manufacturers, distributors, wholesalers and hybrid B2B/DTC brands with complex catalogs, customer-specific pricing, wholesale workflows, ERP or 3PL integrations, and a need for senior technical leadership from strategy through launch.
Our Shopify B2B development work starts with the business rules behind your current store. We map what needs to be preserved, what should be simplified and what Shopify Plus can support without recreating Magento's technical debt. That includes:
- Catalog and product-data review, which also underpins AI search optimization for Shopify
- B2B pricing and customer-account architecture
- ERP, PIM, OMS and 3PL integration planning
- Magento feature and extension audit
- Migration and redirect strategy
- Storefront and checkout planning
- Internal-team workflow design
- Post-launch operating support
For Slingshot Sports, we built a full Shopify B2B implementation that generated seven figures of B2B revenue in 2026.
The goal is not to force every company onto Shopify. It is to determine whether Shopify Plus gives your team a better way to operate. If you are comparing partners, our shortlist of Shopify Plus agencies for high-volume brands includes the questions to ask any of them.
The bottom line
Shopify Plus is a strong B2B platform for mid-market brands that want simpler operations without giving up customer-specific pricing, catalogs, payment terms, account permissions or ERP-connected workflows. Adobe Commerce is still powerful, but its flexibility carries a cost: you need the technical ownership, budget and business case to justify it.
If your B2B business is weighing Shopify Plus against Magento or Adobe Commerce, start with a requirements audit before committing to a migration. See how we approach Shopify B2B, or start with a free Shopify store audit and a 30-minute scoping call. We will tell you whether Shopify Plus is a good fit before you commit to the build.
Frequently asked questions
Should a mid-market B2B brand choose Shopify Plus or Magento?
Can Shopify Plus handle B2B customer-specific pricing?
Can Shopify Plus integrate with an ERP system?
What is the difference between Magento and Adobe Commerce?
When should a B2B business stay on Adobe Commerce?
Sources
- Shopify vs. Adobe Commerce (Magento) comparison (Shopify)
- Introduction to Adobe Commerce B2B (Adobe Experience League)
- B2B ecommerce platforms guide (Shopify)
- B2B ecommerce websites guide (Shopify)
Spotted something wrong or out of date? Email hello@kirkbyconsulting.com with the details and we will correct it.