In short: Match the agency to your complexity, not its logo wall. Kirkby, White Consulting suits 7–9 figure DTC and B2B brands with complex catalogs, pricing or ERP integrations; Domaine suits brand-led enterprise DTC; Anatta suits large high-volume DTC implementations. Ask who scopes and who builds, and ask for proof at your revenue level.
Choosing the wrong Shopify Plus agency at the 7–9 figure revenue level is not just a bad vendor experience. It is a six-month setback, a replatforming that stalls mid-migration, or a B2B build that goes live without working ERP sync. The stakes are high enough that the shortlisting process deserves real rigor.
A note on who wrote this: We're Kirkby, White Consulting, a Shopify Partner agency, and we've included ourselves. We've tried to be straight about where we fit and where other agencies fit better. Every entry has a "best for" callout so you can match your situation to the right partner.
The agencies below were selected on four criteria: demonstrated Shopify Plus specialization, the ability to handle technical complexity (custom pricing, ERP integrations, large catalogs), senior delivery quality, and verifiable client proof. We're listed first because it's our list; the others are in no particular order.
Who this list is for: founders, ecommerce directors and operations leads at DTC and B2B brands generating $5M to $500M+ in annual revenue who are evaluating Shopify Plus partners for a new build, migration or optimization engagement.
No agency on this list is right for every brand.
How to Use This List
Not all Shopify Plus agencies are built for the same kind of work. Some specialize in premium DTC brand builds with heavy creative direction. Others focus on enterprise migrations from Magento or BigCommerce. A few handle complex B2B requirements like wholesale portals, customer-specific pricing and ERP integration.
Before reaching out to any agency, get clear on three things:
- What you're actually building. A Shopify Horizon migration is different from a custom B2B wholesale portal. The agency that excels at one may not be equipped for the other.
- Who will actually do the work. Many agencies sell senior talent and deliver through junior developers. Ask directly: who scopes the project, and who builds it?
- What proof they have at your revenue level. Ask for client references from brands with comparable catalog size, order volume or integration complexity, not just logos.
Use the "best for" callouts below as your first filter. If your situation matches, dig deeper. If it doesn't, move on.
The Shortlist: Shopify Plus Agencies for High-Volume Brands
1. Kirkby, White Consulting
Best for: 7–9 figure DTC and B2B brands with complex catalogs, custom pricing rules, ERP or 3PL integrations, or wholesale requirements that demand senior technical leadership from day one. Not suited for early-stage stores under $1M revenue or brands needing paid media management.
Kirkby, White Consulting is a New York-based Shopify Partner agency run by co-founders James Kirkby and Christopher White. It focuses on DTC and B2B brands in the 7–9 figure range. The firm's defining characteristic is its delivery model: the person who scopes your project is the person responsible for shipping it. There is no account management layer between the client and the work.
The agency works through its Stabilize, Optimize, Grow framework across six service lines: Shopify development, conversion rate optimization, Shopify B2B, strategic ecommerce consulting, ADA and WCAG accessibility, and AI search optimization. The B2B practice covers wholesale portals, customer-specific pricing, ERP and 3PL integrations, and purchase order management.
Notable clients: Michael Stars, Slingshot Sports, Nc'nean, For Play
What clients say:
"In my 20 years working with consultants, James is one of the best, period." — Sean, client
"They were hands-on, knowledgeable, and realistic in their approach. Responsive and timely." — Susan, client
Clutch rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
Starting point: a free store audit and a 30-minute scoping call
2. Domaine
Best for: enterprise DTC brands planning a major website transformation or Shopify Plus roadmap with significant creative and brand direction requirements.
Domaine is a New York-based Shopify Platinum partner, formed in 2023 when the agencies Tomorrow and Half Helix merged. It is a well-regarded choice for established brands that want a premium, design-forward Shopify Plus build, and a strong fit where brand experience and creative direction matter as much as technical delivery.
3. Anatta
Best for: larger, high-volume DTC brands with complex migrations from legacy platforms and ongoing development needs.
Anatta is a Shopify Platinum partner with a strong reputation for large-scale Shopify Plus implementations, including documented work with Vuori, AG1 and Dollar Shave Club.
4. We Make Websites
Best for: high-growth DTC brands in the UK and US looking for a Shopify-specialist agency with a strong track record of consumer brand builds.
We Make Websites is a Shopify-focused agency with offices in London and New York, a large team and a broad portfolio. It is well suited to brands that want a dedicated Shopify partner with significant bench depth and experience across multiple verticals.
5. Barrel
Best for: growing DTC brands that need a specialized Shopify Plus partner with strong creative direction and post-launch optimization capability.
Barrel is a New York-based agency and Shopify Premier partner known for Shopify Plus builds for growing consumer brands. It is a good fit for brands that want a blend of design quality and technical Shopify expertise.
6. Electric Eye
Best for: DTC brands prioritizing revenue growth through conversion optimization, analytics and post-launch performance work.
Electric Eye is a Columbus, Ohio-based Shopify Plus agency focused on optimization and growth strategy, making it a strong fit for brands with an existing Shopify Plus store that want to grow its performance.
Comparison at a Glance
| Agency | Best for | Based in | Known for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kirkby, White Consulting | 7–9 figure DTC and B2B, complex builds | New York | Senior-led delivery; B2B, ERP and wholesale |
| Domaine | Enterprise DTC, brand-forward | New York | Design-led enterprise builds |
| Anatta | Larger high-volume DTC | United States | Large-scale implementations and migrations |
| We Make Websites | High-growth DTC, UK and US | London and New York | Consumer brand builds |
| Barrel | Growing DTC, creative-forward | New York | Design plus technical Shopify work |
| Electric Eye | DTC optimization, post-launch | Columbus, Ohio | Conversion and growth work |
What to Ask Every Agency Before You Sign
The shortlist gets you to the right conversation. These questions get you to the right decision.
On delivery:
- Who will be my primary point of contact throughout the project?
- Who writes the code? Is it the same person who scoped the project?
- Have you worked with brands at our revenue level and catalog complexity before?
On technical fit:
- Have you built a Shopify B2B store with customer-specific pricing and ERP integration?
- What is your process for a Magento-to-Shopify migration with complex product data?
- How do you handle post-launch support and ongoing optimization?
On proof:
- Can you share a case study from a brand with similar complexity to ours?
- What is your Clutch or Google review rating, and can I speak to a reference client?
- What went wrong on a recent project, and how did you handle it?
The last question is the most revealing. Agencies that have never had a project go sideways either haven't done enough work or aren't being honest. The answer tells you more about how they operate under pressure than any portfolio piece.
If you're still deciding whether you need an agency at all, our guide to Shopify agency vs freelancer covers that decision.
The Bottom Line
At the 7–9 figure level, the wrong agency choice costs more than the agency fee. It costs months of delayed revenue, technical debt that takes years to unwind, and a store that was built for someone else's complexity level.
The agencies on this list are all capable. The question is which one is built for your specific situation.
If your brand has complex B2B requirements, a large catalog, or integrations that need to survive a migration, start with our free store audit and a 30-minute scoping call. The audit is a genuine assessment, not a sales pitch, and you will leave with a clear picture of what your store needs and whether we are the right fit.
If we are not, we will tell you that too.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best Shopify Plus agency for a 7–9 figure DTC brand?
How much does a Shopify Plus agency cost?
What is the difference between a Shopify Partner and a Shopify Plus Partner?
How do I evaluate a Shopify Plus agency for B2B requirements?
How long does a Shopify Plus migration take?
What should I look for when hiring a Shopify development agency?
Sources
- About the Shopify Partner Program (Shopify Help Center)
- Shopify Partner Directory
- Kirkby, White Consulting on Clutch
Spotted something wrong or out of date? Email hello@kirkbyconsulting.com with the details and we will correct it.